In a landmark ruling, the Supreme Court of India has clarified the interplay between civil and criminal proceedings in cases of cheque dishonour under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The Court emphasized that while civil judgments are not binding on criminal courts, they are relevant for certain limited purposes such as determining sentences or damages.
Supreme Court on Cheque Dishonour
The case involved parallel civil and criminal proceedings between the same parties regarding a cheque. The appellant had initiated civil proceedings to restrain the encashment of the cheque, while the respondent filed criminal proceedings for cheque dishonour under Section 138 of the Act. The appellant was convicted by the criminal court and sentenced to imprisonment and a fine, while the civil court decreed in favor of the appellant, restraining encashment of the cheque.
The Supreme Court, led by a bench comprising Justices Sanjay Karol and Aravind Kumar, examined the conflict between the civil and criminal court decisions. While acknowledging that civil judgments do not bind criminal courts outright, the Court held that the sentence and damages imposed by the criminal court would be unsustainable if they conflict with a civil court's finding that the cheque was offered as security.
The Court relied on the precedent set in the case of K.G. Premshanker vs. Inspector of Police & Anr, emphasizing that the ratio of civil proceedings would be binding on criminal proceedings for specific purposes, such as sentencing or damages. Additionally, the judgment underscored the principles outlined in the Constitution Bench decision of Iqbal Singh Marwah vs. Meenakshi Marwah, which affirmed that conflicting decisions between civil and criminal courts are not relevant except for limited purposes.
The Supreme Court's ruling clarifies the legal position regarding the impact of civil judgments on criminal proceedings, particularly in cases of cheque dishonour. By setting this precedent, the Court ensures consistency and fairness in judicial proceedings while upholding the principles of justice and equity. This decision reaffirms the importance of considering civil court findings in criminal matters, especially when determining sentences or damages, thereby promoting coherence and integrity within the legal system.
UAE launches ₹23 lakh lifetime visa, opens doors to Indian investors and professionals
Death toll in Telangana pharma plant blast rises to 41, nine still missing
China says Dalai Lama has no say in reincarnation tradition, asserts Beijing’s control over succession
‘I buried hundreds of bodies’: Former sanitation worker blows lid off mass murder cover-up in Karnataka’s Dharmasthala
At least 50 killed, dozens missing in catastrophic Texas flash floods
‘I buried hundreds of bodies’: Former sanitation worker blows lid off mass murder cover-up in Karnataka’s Dharmasthala
Khamenei resurfaces in Tehran after Israeli strikes kill top Iranian commanders
‘Crime capital of India’: Rahul Gandhi slams Nitish govt after Patna tycoon shot dead
India ranks fourth globally in income equality, ahead of China and US
At 90, Dalai Lama pledges to keep spreading compassion in a fractured world
UAE launches ₹23 lakh lifetime visa, opens doors to Indian investors and professionals
Death toll in Telangana pharma plant blast rises to 41, nine still missing
China says Dalai Lama has no say in reincarnation tradition, asserts Beijing’s control over succession
‘I buried hundreds of bodies’: Former sanitation worker blows lid off mass murder cover-up in Karnataka’s Dharmasthala
At least 50 killed, dozens missing in catastrophic Texas flash floods
‘I buried hundreds of bodies’: Former sanitation worker blows lid off mass murder cover-up in Karnataka’s Dharmasthala
Khamenei resurfaces in Tehran after Israeli strikes kill top Iranian commanders
‘Crime capital of India’: Rahul Gandhi slams Nitish govt after Patna tycoon shot dead
India ranks fourth globally in income equality, ahead of China and US
At 90, Dalai Lama pledges to keep spreading compassion in a fractured world
Copyright© educationpost.in 2024 All Rights Reserved.
Designed and Developed by @Pyndertech