Pakistan Army Chief ridiculed at home over rare earth ‘show-and-tell’ with Trump

Pakistan’s Army chief, General Asim Munir, is facing sharp domestic backlash after presenting rare earth minerals to US President Donald Trump — a gesture critics say highlights the military’s deepening involvement in diplomacy, traditionally a civilian domain.

Leading the condemnation, Senator Aimal Wali Khan likened Munir’s display to a shopkeeper flaunting merchandise to a customer. “Our Chief of Army Staff is roaming around with a briefcase containing rare earth minerals. What a joke! It was absolute mockery,” Khan declared in Parliament, a speech that quickly went viral.

The controversy stems from a White House photo showing Trump closely examining a wooden box of minerals handed over by Munir, while Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif looked on from the sidelines.

The exchange followed a closed-door meeting between Pakistani leaders and Trump and coincided with a new memorandum of understanding between Pakistan’s Frontier Works Organisation and US Strategic Metals to jointly explore strategic minerals for defence and technology purposes.

Khan mocked the optics of the moment, saying, “Which Chief of the Army Staff would go around carrying a briefcase with rare earth minerals? It looked like a big, branded store—where a manager watches on happily as a shopkeeper tells a customer to purchase a glittery item.”

The senator questioned Munir’s constitutional authority to conduct diplomatic outreach, calling it a “contempt of Parliament” and an affront to Pakistan’s democratic framework. “In what capacity? Under which law? This is dictatorship… not democracy,” he said, asserting that such actions undermine the elected government and mirror authoritarian practices.

Khan has demanded a joint session of Parliament to seek clarity on Munir’s initiatives, including the Pakistan-Saudi Arabia defence deal, the country’s stance on Trump’s Gaza peace proposal, and the Army chief’s meetings with foreign leaders.

The incident underscores simmering tensions in Pakistan over the military’s expanding role in areas traditionally reserved for civilian leadership, raising questions about accountability, authority, and constitutional boundaries.