The court's decision follows allegations in a PIL that NIRF rankings are based solely on unverified data submitted by institutions, which may include false information to enhance their positions and attract students.
In a recent order, the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court, on March 20, issued an interim stay, preventing the National Board of Accreditation (NBA) and the Union Education Ministry from releasing the 2025 National Institutional Ranking Framework (NIRF) ranking list.
The order came in response to a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by C Chellamuthu of Dindigul, Tamil Nadu, who alleged that the score-calculation process for the rank list was unclear and involved malpractices.
A bench of Justices J Nisha Banu and S Srimathy delivered the judgment.
In his appeal, Chellamuthu claimed that the NIRF rankings are determined solely based on the information submitted by institutions, without any auditing or verification.
According to him, many schools submit fictitious data to boost their rankings and attract students and multinational corporations.
He provided comparative data between the NIRF reports, available online by certain universities, and the AQAR (Annual Quality Assurance Report) reports from the National Assessment and Accreditation Council (NAAC).
He argued that the NIRF reports contain more data than the AQAR reports in areas such as the number of PhD students, faculty, R&D funds, and consulting project funds.
Chellamuthu contended that the discrepancies in the NIRF data suggest that institutions may have falsified their submissions to achieve higher rankings, given that AQAR reports are validated by NAAC’s expert committees.
He claimed that many reputable state universities are excluded while institutions with subpar academic infrastructure and quality manage to secure top rankings.
He warned that such manipulation could harm the country's higher education system.
The petitioner urged the court to direct the Union Ministry and NBA to release the NIRF rankings only after the complete disclosure of the scoring system and thorough verification.
The bench issued an interim order after reviewing the submitted data. The hearing was adjourned until April 24 after the government counsel requested more time to submit a counter-affidavit.
India’s Covid-19 cases go past 6,000, Central Govt ramps up emergency drills
Central Govt clears major iron-ore expansion in Maharastara’s Maoist-hit Gadchiroli tribal forests
Faridabad doctor posed as cardiologist, performed 50 surgeries without qualification
Pakistan’s UNSC bid falls flat, India rallies allies to block key terror panels
Manipur on edge as protesters threaten self-immolation over arrest of ethnic militia leader
India’s Shubhanshu Shukla joins pioneering space study to unlock diabetes care beyond Earth
RBI flags limited policy room after 50 bps rate cut, signals cautious road ahead
Bollywood icon Jeetendra sells 2.3-acre Mumbai Andheri land for ₹855 crore to tech giant
PM Modi opens world’s highest rail bridge, flags off Kashmir’s first Vande Bharat
SC pushes NEET PG to August 3, orders single-shift exam to restore fairness
India’s Covid-19 cases go past 6,000, Central Govt ramps up emergency drills
Central Govt clears major iron-ore expansion in Maharastara’s Maoist-hit Gadchiroli tribal forests
Faridabad doctor posed as cardiologist, performed 50 surgeries without qualification
Pakistan’s UNSC bid falls flat, India rallies allies to block key terror panels
Manipur on edge as protesters threaten self-immolation over arrest of ethnic militia leader
India’s Shubhanshu Shukla joins pioneering space study to unlock diabetes care beyond Earth
RBI flags limited policy room after 50 bps rate cut, signals cautious road ahead
Bollywood icon Jeetendra sells 2.3-acre Mumbai Andheri land for ₹855 crore to tech giant
PM Modi opens world’s highest rail bridge, flags off Kashmir’s first Vande Bharat
SC pushes NEET PG to August 3, orders single-shift exam to restore fairness
Copyright© educationpost.in 2024 All Rights Reserved.
Designed and Developed by @Pyndertech